"No Added Sugar" vs. "Sugar Free": What the Labels Really Mean
2026-09-24
"No added sugar" on the juice, "sugar free" on the cereal, "no refined sugar" on the bar. They look like the same promise on the shelf. They aren't, and the difference matters if you're watching your blood sugar.
What the claims mean under US rules
The FDA defines these claims fairly narrowly:
- "Sugar free": less than 0.5 g of sugars per reference amount and per labeled serving, and no ingredient that is itself a sugar (with limited exceptions that carry a disclaimer).
- "No added sugars": no sugars, and no ingredients containing sugars that function as sweeteners (juice concentrate, for example), were added during processing. The sugar naturally in the ingredients is still there.
The catch: "no added sugars" says nothing about how much sugar the product ends up with. A juice made from concentrate can carry the claim and still deliver a lot of sugar per glass.
Where the confusion comes from
- "No refined sugar" and similar phrases have no fixed definition. Agave nectar, rice syrup and date paste are all fair game.
- "Sugar free" doesn't rule out sugar alcohols (maltitol, sorbitol) or maltodextrin. Depending on the ingredient they may not count as "sugars" on the panel, yet some still raise blood glucose.
- Rounding: amounts under 0.5 g can be declared as "0 g" on the panel, so "0 g" doesn't always mean none.
A ten-second check
- Read Added Sugars on the Nutrition Facts panel, not just Total Sugars.
- Scan the first five ingredients for syrups, "-ose" words and maltodextrin (see our list of hidden sugar names).
- Treat the front of the package as advertising. The ingredient list is the part manufacturers are required to get right.
If you're on a GLP-1 medication or managing prediabetes, this habit filters out most of the traps in a single pass.
Frequently asked questions
What does "sugar free" mean under FDA rules?
Less than 0.5 g of sugars per reference amount and per labeled serving, and no ingredient that is itself a sugar (with limited exceptions that carry a disclaimer).
What does "no added sugars" mean?
No sugars, and no ingredients containing sugars that function as sweeteners (juice concentrate, for example), were added during processing. The sugar naturally in the ingredients is still there.
Does "sugar free" mean the product has no sweeteners?
No. It does not rule out sugar alcohols or maltodextrin. For maltodextrin, see Maltodextrin: is it sugar?.
Can a label say 0 g when there is some sugar?
Yes. Amounts under 0.5 g can be declared as "0 g" on the panel, so "0 g" does not always mean none.
This article is general information, not medical advice.
DE · ES