"Product not found." Anyone who regularly uses barcode-based scanner apps such as Yuka knows this message. It is not a one-off: user reviews keep describing products that are not listed, especially lesser-known items.
Most well-known scanner apps follow the same principle. The barcode is scanned and matched against a database that is either maintained by users or supplied by manufacturers. That works well for large, established brands, and less well once a product is new on the shelf, imported from abroad, or has changed its recipe without anyone updating the database entry.
Another effect users describe in reviews: the same product is rated differently when scanned again months later, without any visible reason.
The Verbraucherzentrale, a German consumer protection organisation, tested Yuka (as of 6 June 2024). In its sample of 100 branded and store-brand products, more than 80 percent were recognised. Missing products can be added by entering basic details and photographing the ingredient list; in the test this took 45 minutes, and the app says up to 24 hours. So the gap is real but smaller than the complaints suggest. It is most noticeable for regional products and small producers.
Technically the problem can be avoided if an app does not rely only on a pre-filled database and, for an unknown barcode, analyses a photo of the ingredient list directly. The result then does not depend on whether someone else has already scanned this exact product; every check reads the current ingredient list on the pack in front of you. The trade-off: a photo analysis can make mistakes, so it should be double-checked on the pack.
A database is never completely up to date; that is in the nature of things, not a lack of effort by the providers. If you want a reliable assessment even for unknown or new products, choose a tool that can read the label when the database has no entry, and check important results on the pack.
This article is general information and not medical advice. Features of third-party apps can change.
The HiddenSugar app shows you sugar on ingredient lists by barcode scan or photo.
Get it on Google Play